Apple iPhone vs. Apple iPod Touch
By CNET Staff
JUDGES: Kent German, Donald Bell, and Tom Krazit
Barely three months after the launch of the iPhone, Apple debuted its iPod Touch. Though their similar designs may lead you to think that the Touch is just an iPhone without the phone, in reality they are two distinct devices. Variations in style, features, and media performance become readily apparent to those that dig a little deeper. That’s why CNET pitted these two devices against each other to see which one is the superior multimedia player. Of course, we can’t compare call quality, so that will be left out of the tussle, but certainly we can compare almost everything else.
Let’s have a clean fight, fellas. Ding, ding!
About the judges
Kent German covers cell phones at CNET and has been following the wireless industry for six years. He’s embarrassed to admit he can name almost any cell phone he sees on the street.
Donald Bell covers all the latest portable audio and video gadgets. He reviews everything from the smallest digital audio players to tablet-size video players.
Tom Krazit covers anything and everything related to Apple for CNET News.com, tracking what Apple is doing and where it is going as the company’s influence on the technology industry hits an all-time high.
Round 1: Sexiness
Sleek and sleeker
![]()
Apple iPhone
The iPhone and the iTouch may look like identical twins at first glance, but these siblings each has its own style. So which is easier on the eyes? Our individual judges’ ratings are based on a 0-to-5-point scale, which results in a final score of 0 to 15 points per round.
| Player | Kent | Donald | Tom | Total |
Round 2: Features
Real beauty is on the inside
![]()
Apple iPhone
What do the iPhone and iPod Touch offer under the hood? Here, we examine the features in each device and decide if one offers more. Remember, we’re excluding the iPod Touch’s lack of calling features from this comparison.
| Player | Kent | Donald | Tom | Total |
Round 3: Media quality
Which has the more powerful multimedia punch?
![]()
Apple iPhone
Though their music quality is the same, the difference in screen size between the two devices and the iPod Touch’s lack of exterior speakers may affect video performance. We tell if that’s true.
| Player | Kent | Donald | Tom | Total |
Winner: Apple iPhone
The winner is…

Apple iPhone
Total points:
Apple iPhone: 39
Apple iPod Touch: 34
Winner: Apple iPhoneQuick story brought to you by Cnet.








![[Valid RSS]](valid-rss.png)


Recent Comments